During the ancient times, the concept of rule of law was discussed by the greek philosopher aristotle and plato at the time of 350 bc so now you can imagine how old this concept. Therefore, the rule of law enforces a standard of fairness. Diceys rule of law consists of following three meanings. Albert venn dicey, born february 4, 1835, near lutterworth, leicestershire, englanddied april 7, 1922, oxford, british jurist whose lectures introductory to the study of the law of the constitution 1885 is considered part of the british constitution, which is an amalgam of several written and unwritten authorities. However, several criticism have been made against diceys theory of rule of law. A law utterly opposed to the wishes and feelings entertained by the inhabitants of a country, a rule which every one dislikes and no one will obey, is a nullity, or in truth no law at all. It is also seen as an integral part of good governance. Rule of law is a product of struggle by the people from centuries for recognition of their inherent rights and the concept of a rule is very ancient and old. Diceys study of the law of the constitution 1885 has been since its publication the dominant analysis of the british constitution and the source of orthodoxy on such subjects as parliamentary sovereignty and the rule of law. It has been said that diceys concept lacks support from precedents, and is inherently fallacious because the nature of sovereign power is contrary to the idea of the parliament.
New editions were issued by the same publisher in 1886, 1889,1893,1897, 1902, and 1908. Albert venn dicey kc fba 18351922, usually cited as a. It is undoubtedly one that is capable of differing interpretations and thus the actual meaning is often evasive. He became vinerian professor of english law at oxford and a leading. Diceys exposition of rule is base on holy misconception.
The hon kevin lindgren am qc, outlines professor albert venn diceys three features of the rule of law and comments on their relevance today. This was based on the ecjs preliminary ruling that community law must be interpreted as meaning that a national court which, in a case before it concerning community law, considers that the sole obstacle which precludes it from granting interim relief is a rule of national law must set aside that rule 5. And yet dicey was forced to acknowledge that imperial rule at times required arbitrariness and formal inequality at. The concept of rule of law according to av dicey law has one single purpose, to establish principles that facilitate equal treatment of human beings and ensuring social stability. Diceys late nineteenthcentury restatement of the ruleoflaw doctrine comprised three elements. Basic constitutional principles became commonly conceived in diceyan terms. Stripped of all technicalities the ideal of the rule of law means that government in all its actions is bound by rules fixed and announced beforehand rules which make it possible to foresee with fair certainty how the authority will. Diceys rule of law posted on october 25, 2015 by manishwrose the rule of law is the legal principle that law is the supreme and law should govern a nation, as opposed to being governed by arbitrary decisions of individual government officials. In each of these editions, dicey attempted to reflect such constitutional changes as he believed had occurred since the previous edition. In this lesson charu throws light on judiciary, its role, functions and structure of courts in india.
It means in the first place, the absolute supremacy or predominance of regular law as opposed to the influence of. Among them are that law and order in contrast to anarchy. It remains, to this day, a starting point for the study of the english constitution and comparative constitutional law. The problem that arises with this is arbitrary power is broader than the rule of law. Diceys first principle of the rule of law was that no man is punishable or can be lawfully made to suffer in body or goods except for a distinct breach of law established in the ordinary legal manner before the ordinary courts of the land. Constitution is a rule of law, however not all constitution follows the theory of rule of law. Its origins and meanings a short guide for practitioners article pdf available march 2012 with 18,604 reads how we measure reads. The rule of law and why i think it matters legal cheek. Diceys rule of law indian news, law news on indian law. The concept of rule of law backs to the time of aristotle.
As dicey might have predicted, the shift away from hardedged commonlaw rules to openended constitutional balancing corresponds to a marked loss of relative. It requires the government to exercise its powers in accordance with established and clearly written rules, regulations and legal principles. The rule of law is emphasised through many separate ideas. Theres so much more to the rule of law than dicey, and its hard to endorse or reject any particular viewpoint without a fuller understanding of what the rule of law actually is. Rule of law rule of law can be direct translated to rule according to law. Dicey, was a british whig jurist and constitutional theorist. The idea of the rule of law, more ubiquitous globally today than ever before, owes a lasting debt to the work of victorian legal theorist a. Dicey, parliamentary sovereignty and the rule of law uni. Fallacy of diceys aspect of the welfare state and rule of law. Whereas the rule of law is still the one of the very important principles regulating in common law countries and common law derived countries modern laws has denied some of the important parts of rule of law as proposed by dicey at the start of 19th century. It means that there shall be no distinction between the rich and the poor, officials and nonofficials,majority and minority, no one can be degraded and no one can be upgraded. A v diceys introduction to the study of the law of the constitution was first published in 1885 in london by macmillan and co. Dicey, rule of law has three means or we can say three principles which are must be.
Craig argues that this branch of diceys rule of law had no teeth once discretionary acts took statutory form. Dicey argued this point further in his lectures on the relation between law and public opinion in england during the nineteenth century, lecture 11 2d ed. The rule of law comprises a number of principles of a formal and procedural character. The rule of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The first rule of law by dicey talks about the supremacy of law as opposed to the arbitrariness of governments power. It describes concepts like integrated judiciary and pil. The formulation of the rule of law is founded by a. Plato and aristotle observed that natural law is a legal concept that explores. Albert venn dicey described the rule of law as acting in three ways. For these reasons, diceys discussion of the rule of law and its relation to it documents that the original understanding of the rule of law included substantive.
But for all of diceys influence, very little attention has been paid to the imperial entanglements of his thought, including on the rule of law. The third part of the constitution of india puts forward basic rights that are guaranteed, as subject to the protection and forcible action of the court. A year after the publication of diceys law of the constitution, william gladstone was reading it aloud in the house of commons, citing it as authority. Thus, social stability and equality can only be achieved if law is allowed to preside over the people and that is what is called rule of law. The principles it expounds are considered part of the uncodified british constitution. Albert venn dicey and the principles of the rule of law. The rule of law lecture notes on the topic the rule of. It is therefore not surprising that his theory is used as a reference in the rule of law of many countries around the world nowadays. Equality before the law, or the equal subjection of all classes to the ordinary law of the land administrated by the ordinary law courts1 here dicey is saying that we are all not only subject to law, but equal before it, irrespective of our role in the society. The supremacy of the law of the land was not a novel doctrine in nineteenth century where a. The rule of law is the legal principle that law is the supreme and law should govern a nation, as opposed to being governed by arbitrary decisions of individual government officials. The law of the constitution oxford edition of dicey 1st.
Text, cases etc the rule of law is widely acknowledged to be an essential. The concept of rule or law css constitutional law notes. Rule of law and modern administrative law by vivek ranjan. It deals with factors that are important to law making.
Diceys theory of rule of law consists of three main principles. He is most widely known as the author of introduction to the study of the law of the constitution 1885. The rule of law refers to various established legal principles imposing limitations on governmental authority. Rule of law series part 2 diceys rule of law youtube. V diceys comment on the rule of law, it is imperative to establish a sound understanding of the concept of the rule of law. Rule of law international journal of law and legal. Diceys third point completely ignored the role of statute in the constitution. Diceys rule of law unless explicitly noted, quotes within this section are from diceys law of the constitution the notion of the rule of law can be traced back to at least the time of aristotle who observed that given the choice between a king who ruled by discretion and a king who ruled by law, the later was clearly superior to the former. For this treatise, which is noted for its application of legal. Questi ons are though raised as to the extent to which the constitutional promise of the rule of law matches with actual situation in india. On diceys account, the rule of law represented a distinctive english civilisational achievement, one that furnished a liberal justification for british imperialism. The rule of law lecture notes on the topic the rule of law. The indian constitution took up and makes use of diceys rule of law.
Many forms of arbitrary rule are compatible with the rule of law. Thus, the rule of law must be supported by a judicial system which is free and independent from any extraneous interference which. There must be a single, ultimate and unlimited law making power. Diceys theory of the rule of law dicey wrote that the rule of law had three meanings, or may be regarded from three different points of view. The rule of law requires that people should be governed by accepted rules, rather than by the.
The second meaning of diceys rule of law 728 words. It is comprised of the key factors of justice, liberty, and equality. Dicey thought that the supremacy of the rule of law contained three distinct though related concepts. Though the idea of the rule of law was not introduced by dicey, he may be credited for popularising it. Inherent ambiguity decision of parliament always based on majoritys decision. Development of the rule of law legal service india.
The 2011 sir david williams lecture professor jeremy waldron duration. The phrase rule of law was popularized in the 19th century by british jurist and constitutional theorist a. The three principles of diceys rol have to a degree all remained relevant today as there is largely a supremacy of regular law, there is equality before the law, and the continued existence of an ordinary law constitution. The theories of dicey, hayek and unger, which comprise the dominant. Chapter iv, the first chapter within that part, was headed the rule of law. The rule of law is also inevitably linked with the independence of the judiciary as upholding the various principles supporting the rule of law is one of the constitutional responsibilities given to the judiciary. Introduction to the study of the law of the constitution. The second meaning of diceys rule of law the second meaning of diceys rule of law states. Rule of law once had an important place in political theory and it would be useful to compare its current and.
186 1264 1548 1470 476 504 563 106 442 1363 527 44 957 282 434 530 281 239 1149 1571 611 578 1352 871 13 1104 1133 217 511 209 1192 1297 624